How do you analyse board feedback when directors select “not applicable”?

Analyse “not applicable” responses by treating them as data rather than gaps. Separate valid N/A answers, which reflect genuine irrelevance to a director’s role, from evasive ones, which signal discomfort, disengagement or lack of information. Then examine patterns by question, director and committee before deciding how to score and report them.

The distinction matters because a single N/A rarely tells the full story, while a cluster of them often points to a structural or cultural issue the Board has not yet named. The sections below set out how to interpret, score, report and reduce N/A responses in a board evaluation.

What does a “not applicable” response usually signal?

A “not applicable” response usually signals one of three things: the question genuinely does not relate to the director’s role, the director lacks the information to answer, or the director prefers not to answer. Each cause demands a different interpretation and a different response from the Board.

The first cause is legitimate. A member who does not sit on the audit committee cannot fairly rate its effectiveness. The second cause points to an information or access problem: if directors cannot assess risk oversight or succession planning, the Board may not be receiving the visibility those topics require. The third cause is the most sensitive. Directors sometimes select N/A to avoid criticising a colleague, the Chair or the CEO, particularly in smaller boards where responses feel traceable.

Treat every N/A as a prompt for inquiry. The response itself carries no score, yet it frequently carries more governance insight than a rating of three out of five.

How can you tell a valid N/A from avoidance?

Tell a valid N/A from avoidance by testing it against the director’s role and against the pattern of responses. A valid N/A aligns with committee membership, tenure or remit. Avoidance shows up as N/A selected on questions the director is clearly positioned to answer, especially those touching dynamics, leadership or accountability.

Apply four checks:

  • Role fit: Does the director’s committee membership, tenure or portfolio explain the response?
  • Question type: Are N/A answers concentrated on sensitive topics such as Chair performance, CEO relationship or peer contribution?
  • Consistency: Does the director use N/A across many questions, or only a few that share a theme?
  • Written comments: Do free-text responses elsewhere contradict the N/A, showing the director holds a view?

A new director with six months’ tenure who marks N/A on long-term strategy review is behaving reasonably. A seasoned director who marks N/A on the quality of boardroom debate is telling you something different.

Should N/A responses be counted in board scores?

No. N/A responses should be excluded from the numerical average, because counting them as zero or as a neutral midpoint distorts the result. Instead, report the N/A rate alongside each score so readers can judge how much weight the rating deserves.

Excluding N/A keeps the score an honest reflection of those qualified to rate the item. However, a score built on three responses out of ten is a weaker signal than one built on ten, and the report must say so. A practical convention is to flag any item where N/A responses exceed a set threshold, for example one quarter of respondents, and present the score with a clear caveat.

Avoid the temptation to recode N/A as a mid-scale rating. That practice hides the very information the Board most needs: where its members feel unable to form a view.

How should N/A patterns be reported to the Chair?

Report N/A patterns to the Chair as a dedicated finding, separate from the scored results, and present them by theme rather than by individual. Anonymity must hold. The goal is to show where the Board lacks visibility or candour, not to identify who withheld a view.

A concise reporting structure works well:

  1. Headline pattern: State which topics drew the highest N/A rates.
  2. Likely cause: Distinguish role-related, information-related and candour-related explanations, with the reasoning behind each.
  3. Implication: Explain what the pattern means for oversight, for example weak visibility on cyber risk or reluctance to assess the Chair.
  4. Recommended response: Propose a specific next step for the Chair to consider.

Company Secretaries are well placed to prepare this view, since they understand committee structures and can quickly separate legitimate N/A responses from those that need attention. Frank reporting serves the Chair better than a softened summary.

What follow-up actions should N/A results trigger?

N/A results should trigger targeted follow-up proportionate to the cause. Information gaps call for improved briefings or training. Role-related N/A responses may call for revised questionnaire routing. Candour-related patterns call for a confidential conversation, ideally led by an independent party rather than a peer.

Practical actions include:

  • Arranging deep-dive sessions on topics where many directors felt unable to respond.
  • Reviewing board packs and induction material to confirm directors receive what they need to exercise oversight.
  • Holding one-to-one discussions between the Chair, or an external facilitator, and directors whose patterns suggest reluctance.
  • Adding the finding to the multi-year development plan so progress is tracked, not forgotten.

A single evaluation cycle will rarely resolve a cultural issue. Track whether the N/A rate on a given topic falls in the next cycle. A declining rate is a reliable sign that visibility and openness are improving.

How can survey design reduce unnecessary N/A answers?

Survey design reduces unnecessary N/A answers by routing questions to the directors qualified to answer them, writing items in clear and observable terms, and giving a distinct alternative for those who prefer not to respond. Clear design makes the remaining N/A responses far more meaningful.

Consider these design principles:

  • Role-based routing: Show committee questions only to committee members, so N/A is not used as a workaround.
  • Precise wording: Replace abstract items such as “the Board manages risk well” with observable statements that directors can assess from experience.
  • Separate options: Offer “no basis to judge” distinct from “prefer not to say,” so the two causes are not blended.
  • Open comments: Invite a short explanation whenever N/A is selected, which converts silence into insight.
  • Protected anonymity: Confirm how responses are handled, since fear of identification is a leading driver of avoidance.

Thoughtful board effectiveness evaluation design pays off at the analysis stage, because cleaner inputs produce findings the Chair can act on with confidence.

How The Board Practice helps with analysing N/A responses

The Board Practice brings more than 19 years of refined methodology to board evaluation, including the interpretation of what directors choose not to say. Led by Dr. Victor Prozesky, who has taken part in over 120 board performance programmes, the firm works in close partnership with the Chair to read response patterns honestly and turn them into forward-looking action. The AI-powered platform, launching on 1 August 2026, extends this capability by supporting questionnaire selection, evaluation completion and analysis with actionable recommendations.

  • Bespoke questionnaire design that routes questions by role and limits unnecessary N/A answers.
  • Candid analysis that separates legitimate N/A responses from avoidance, with strengths and development areas reported together.
  • Confidential reporting to the Chair, with multi-year development plans and progress monitoring.
  • Continuous tracking of board performance through the new platform, so N/A trends are visible from one cycle to the next.

To discuss how your next evaluation can surface the insight behind every response, contact The Board Practice.

Related Articles