When a CEO is underperforming, the board must act — and act decisively. The board’s primary obligation is to the organisation’s long-term health, and that obligation does not pause out of loyalty or discomfort. Addressing CEO underperformance is one of the most consequential responsibilities a board holds, and how it handles that process reveals the true quality of its governance. The questions below address each stage of that process, from early recognition through to structural safeguards.
What are the signs that a CEO is underperforming?
A CEO is underperforming when there is a sustained and material gap between what the organisation requires of its leader and what that leader is delivering. The signs span financial, strategic, cultural, and relational dimensions — and boards that wait for financial metrics alone to confirm underperformance often act far too late.
The most visible indicators include missed strategic milestones, consistent failure to meet agreed performance targets, and an inability to build or retain a capable executive team. But underperformance is often first visible in softer signals: a loss of board confidence, deteriorating relationships with key stakeholders, cultural disengagement within the organisation, or a CEO who has stopped bringing difficult issues to the board’s attention.
- Strategic drift: The organisation is not executing against its stated direction, and the CEO cannot account for the gap.
- Leadership erosion: Senior talent is departing, or the executive team lacks cohesion and direction.
- Communication breakdown: The board is receiving incomplete, delayed, or overly curated information.
- Stakeholder deterioration: Relationships with investors, regulators, or major clients are declining without adequate response.
- Cultural warning signs: Employee engagement, internal escalations, or whistleblower activity suggests leadership is failing at the organisational level.
Boards should resist the tendency to attribute these signals to external conditions alone. Context matters, but the board’s role is to assess leadership effectiveness within that context — not to excuse it.
Whose responsibility is it to address CEO underperformance?
It is the board’s responsibility — specifically, it falls to the Chair in the first instance, with the full board accountable for the outcome. The CEO serves at the board’s discretion. While the Chair typically leads direct engagement with the CEO on performance matters, the board as a whole must be aligned on the assessment and the path forward.
In practice, this means the Chair must be willing to have frank, direct conversations that other leaders might avoid. The non-executive directors must be prepared to form an independent view, free from the influence of a CEO who may have cultivated strong personal relationships over time. Where a nomination or remuneration committee exists, it plays a supporting role — but accountability cannot be delegated away from the full board.
One of the most common governance failures in this area is a board that recognises underperformance but defers action indefinitely, waiting for the situation to resolve itself. It rarely does. The longer a board delays, the more costly the eventual intervention becomes — to the organisation, to stakeholders, and to the board’s own credibility.
How should a board raise performance concerns with a CEO?
A board should raise performance concerns directly, privately, and through the Chair — with documented clarity about what is expected, what has fallen short, and what improvement looks like. The conversation must be honest without being personal, and structured without being bureaucratic.
The Chair should initiate a confidential, one-on-one discussion with the CEO that makes the board’s concerns explicit. Vague feedback is not only ineffective — it is unfair to the CEO and leaves the board exposed if formal action becomes necessary later. The concerns raised should be specific, tied to agreed performance criteria, and accompanied by a clear timeframe for review.
Following that initial conversation, the board should formalise its expectations in writing. This is not about creating a paper trail for dismissal — it is about ensuring that both parties share a common understanding of what improvement requires. A performance improvement framework, agreed between the Chair and CEO, should include measurable outcomes, a realistic timeline, and a defined review process.
Throughout this process, confidentiality is essential. Premature disclosure of CEO performance concerns can destabilise the organisation, unsettle markets, and undermine the CEO’s ability to lead through the improvement period. The board must manage this with discretion.
What formal steps can a board take when CEO performance does not improve?
When performance does not improve following structured feedback and a defined review period, the board must escalate to formal intervention — which may ultimately include termination of the CEO’s appointment. The board should follow a clear, documented process that is legally sound, procedurally fair, and strategically considered.
Formal performance review
The board convenes a formal assessment of the CEO’s performance against the agreed improvement criteria. This review should involve the full board or a designated sub-committee, and its findings should be documented with precision. If the board concludes that the required improvement has not been achieved, it must be prepared to act on that conclusion.
Transition and separation
Where the board determines that the CEO’s continued tenure is not in the organisation’s interest, it must manage the transition with the same discipline it would apply to any major strategic decision. This includes legal and contractual considerations, a communication strategy for internal and external stakeholders, and — critically — a plan for leadership continuity. A board that removes a CEO without a credible succession pathway compounds one crisis with another.
How does CEO succession planning reduce the risk of prolonged underperformance?
CEO succession planning reduces the risk of prolonged underperformance by ensuring the board is never without a credible path forward. When succession planning is embedded as an ongoing governance practice rather than an emergency response, the board retains the confidence to act decisively — because it already knows what comes next.
The most effective boards treat succession planning as a continuous process that begins the moment a CEO is appointed. This means maintaining an updated view of internal candidates, understanding the external market, and regularly assessing whether the current CEO’s profile continues to match the organisation’s evolving strategic requirements.
Boards that lack a succession plan are effectively held hostage by the current CEO’s tenure. The perceived cost of removing an underperforming CEO becomes artificially high when there is no prepared alternative. This dynamic allows underperformance to persist far longer than it should — and it is entirely preventable through disciplined forward planning.
When should a board bring in external governance advisors?
A board should bring in external governance advisors when it lacks the objectivity, experience, or process rigour to manage CEO performance concerns internally — and in most cases, that threshold is reached earlier than boards tend to acknowledge. The presence of longstanding relationships, competing loyalties, and institutional inertia makes genuine objectivity difficult to sustain from within.
External advisors are particularly valuable in three circumstances: when the board is divided on its assessment of the CEO’s performance; when the organisation is navigating a concurrent strategic or regulatory challenge that complicates the performance conversation; and when the board has not previously conducted a structured CEO performance review and lacks a methodology to do so.
An experienced external advisor brings a tested process, the credibility to ask difficult questions without internal consequence, and the ability to benchmark the board’s own effectiveness as part of the review. In many cases, CEO underperformance is intertwined with structural governance issues — unclear mandates, weak performance frameworks, or a board that has not been holding itself to the same standard it applies to the CEO.
How The Board Practice supports boards navigating CEO performance challenges
The Board Practice works directly with boards facing some of the most consequential governance decisions an organisation encounters — including CEO performance, succession, and the structural conditions that allow underperformance to take hold. The firm’s approach is built on intellectual rigour, candid counsel, and a commitment to outcomes that are genuinely forward-looking.
- Board Effectiveness Evaluation: A fully customised assessment that examines not just individual director performance but the board’s collective capacity to hold leadership accountable — including the CEO. The process goes well beyond compliance, focusing on board dynamics, decision-making quality, and strategic alignment.
- CEO Succession Planning: Grounded in the principle that succession planning begins on the day of appointment, the firm helps boards build and maintain a credible succession framework that removes the paralysis that often accompanies CEO underperformance.
- Independent advisory: Where boards require an objective external perspective to navigate a specific performance challenge, The Board Practice provides frank, confidential counsel — working in close partnership with the Chair to define the path forward.
- Proprietary assessment tools: For boards seeking to strengthen their own evaluation processes, the firm’s board evaluation software enables structured, self-directed assessments that build the governance muscle needed to manage CEO performance with confidence.
Boards that act early, with the right support, consistently achieve better outcomes than those that delay. If your board is navigating concerns about CEO performance or wants to strengthen the governance structures that prevent prolonged underperformance, contact The Board Practice to discuss how a tailored engagement can help.
Related Articles
- How do you separate evidence from assumptions in AI-generated board findings?
- How should directors be informed about AI use in a board evaluation?
- What is the difference between a strong board and a weak board and how does AI tell you which one you have?
- What is a board development program?
- How should the full board be involved in evaluating executive performance?