Before choosing a board evaluation platform, confirm that it exports complete data, including raw responses, in open formats such as CSV, Excel, and PDF. Also confirm who owns the data, how exports are secured, whether results can be compared year over year, and what happens to your records when the contract ends.
For a Company Secretary, these checks determine whether the evaluation record remains a governance asset or becomes a dependency on one vendor. The questions below set out what to verify before you sign.
Which export formats should a board evaluation platform support?
A board evaluation platform should support at least one structured, machine-readable format (CSV or Excel) and one presentation-ready format (PDF). Structured exports allow analysis and archiving. Formatted exports serve board packs, committee discussions, and regulator or investor requests.
Test each format against a real use case rather than a feature list. A PDF report suits the Chair’s feedback session. A CSV or Excel file suits trend analysis, cross-referencing with skills matrices, and long-term retention. Where the platform offers an API or bulk download, ask whether it covers the entire dataset or only the current evaluation cycle.
Check also that exports preserve structure. Question wording, rating scales, response dates, and respondent categories should travel with the data. A file containing scores without the questions that produced them is of limited use two years later.
Does an export include raw responses or only summary reports?
Many platforms export only summary reports, such as averages, charts, and thematic narratives. Raw responses, meaning the individual ratings and free-text comments beneath those summaries, are often available only on request or only in higher service tiers. Confirm in writing that raw data is included in standard exports.
Raw responses matter for three reasons:
- Independent verification. The board can test whether a summary fairly represents the underlying input.
- Custom analysis. Responses can be segmented by committee, tenure, or role without relying on the vendor’s reporting logic.
- Continuity. If you change provider, raw data lets you rebuild historical baselines.
Raw data also raises a confidentiality question. Directors answer candidly when they trust that attribution is controlled. Ask how the platform handles anonymisation in exports, and whether free-text comments can be exported in a form that protects individual respondents. Candid feedback is the foundation of a rigorous evaluation, and an export function that undermines that trust defeats the purpose.
Who owns board evaluation data after export?
The organisation commissioning the evaluation should own all evaluation data, including responses, reports, and derived analysis. The contract should state this explicitly, and it should restrict the vendor to processing the data only for the purpose of delivering the service.
Review the following clauses before agreeing terms:
- Ownership and licence. Confirm there is no clause granting the vendor rights to reuse your data beyond service delivery.
- Aggregation and benchmarking. If the vendor uses anonymised data to build benchmarks, ask how anonymity is guaranteed for a small board where individuals are easily identified.
- AI training. Ask whether your data may be used to train or refine any models. Board evaluation content is among the most sensitive material an organisation holds.
- Data controller and processor roles. Under data protection law, the organisation is typically the controller. The contract should reflect that.
Ownership also has a governance dimension. Evaluation outcomes feed development plans, succession decisions, and disclosures to regulators and investors. The board, not a vendor, must retain control of that record.
How secure is the board evaluation data export process?
A secure export process encrypts data in transit and at rest, restricts who can trigger an export, and logs every export event. Because evaluation data often includes candid views on individual directors and the Chair, export security deserves the same scrutiny as the platform’s login security.
Ask the vendor to document the following:
- Role-based permissions that limit export rights, ideally to the Company Secretary and Chair.
- Audit trails recording who exported what, and when.
- Encrypted download links with expiry, rather than open email attachments.
- Independent security assurance, such as ISO 27001 certification or a SOC 2 report.
- Data hosting location, which matters for boards subject to European data protection requirements.
Consider what happens after the file leaves the platform. An exported spreadsheet saved to a shared drive loses every control the vendor applied. Set an internal protocol for storage, access, and retention so the export does not become the weakest link.
Can exported evaluation data be compared year over year?
Exported data supports year-over-year comparison only if questions, scales, and respondent categories remain consistent between cycles, and if the export retains those identifiers. Without that consistency, trend analysis becomes unreliable, and the board loses its clearest view of whether development actions are working.
Examine three points:
- Question stability. Can you retain a core set of questions across cycles while adding topical ones? Look for question IDs or versioning in the export.
- Historical access. Can you export multiple cycles in a single, consistently structured dataset?
- Context fields. Does the export record board composition, committee membership, and cycle dates, so shifts in results can be interpreted correctly?
Trend data is most valuable when tied to a multi-year development plan. A board that commits to two or three years of improvement priorities needs a dependable baseline to judge progress. The data structure must therefore outlast any single evaluation or, indeed, any single vendor relationship.
What happens to the data if the platform contract ends?
When a contract ends, the vendor should return all data in an open format within a defined period, then delete it and certify the deletion. If the contract is silent on these points, the board carries the risk of losing its evaluation history or leaving sensitive data with a former supplier.
Secure the following terms before signing:
- Return period. A defined window, such as 30 to 90 days, during which a complete export remains available after termination.
- Format commitment. Return in open, documented formats, not proprietary files that only the vendor’s software can read.
- Deletion certification. Written confirmation that data, including backups, has been permanently deleted after return.
- Transition support. Clarity on whether assistance is available and at what cost.
- Retention obligations. Alignment with your records policy and any legal retention duty.
These clauses address vendor lock-in directly. The practical test is simple: could you leave this platform tomorrow and retain a complete, usable record? If the answer is uncertain, negotiate before commitment, not after.
How The Board Practice helps with board evaluation data and platform selection
The Board Practice has refined its board effectiveness methodology over more than 19 years, working with boards across industries and continents. Its AI-powered board platform, launching on 1 August 2026, was designed with the governance concerns of Company Secretaries in mind. It supports boards in:
- Generating or selecting questionnaires and completing evaluations within one environment.
- Receiving AI-powered analysis with actionable recommendations, not only scores.
- Tracking board performance continuously, so year-over-year comparison is built into the process.
- Combining scalable technology with candid, experienced counsel on what the results mean for the board.
If you are assessing platforms and want a clear view of the questions that matter for your board, contact The Board Practice to discuss your evaluation approach.
Related Articles
- How do you combine director interviews with questionnaire results in an AI-assisted evaluation?
- Can AI analysis detect software vulnerabilities automatically?
- What should be on a board meeting agenda?
- How should a board prepare for an unplanned CEO departure in 2026?
- How long does a thorough board evaluation take to complete?