Who is in charge of corporate governance?

The board of directors holds primary responsibility for corporate governance. In any well-structured organisation, the board is the highest governing authority — accountable to shareholders and stakeholders for how the organisation is directed, controlled, and held to account. That said, governance responsibility is not the board’s alone. It is distributed across a defined set of roles, each with distinct accountabilities, and understanding how those roles interact is essential for any organisation seeking genuine board effectiveness.

What does the board of directors actually govern?

The board of directors governs the overall direction, oversight, and accountability of an organisation. This includes setting strategic direction, approving major decisions, overseeing executive leadership, managing risk, and ensuring that the organisation operates with integrity and in the long-term interests of its stakeholders. Corporate governance, at its core, is the board’s mandate.

More specifically, the board’s governance responsibilities typically encompass the following areas:

  • Strategy: Approving and guiding long-term strategic direction, not managing day-to-day execution
  • Risk oversight: Ensuring that material risks are identified, understood, and appropriately managed
  • Financial integrity: Overseeing financial reporting, audit processes, and the accuracy of disclosures
  • Leadership accountability: Appointing, evaluating, and where necessary, replacing the CEO
  • Culture and values: Setting the tone from the top and holding the organisation to its stated values
  • Stakeholder interests: Balancing the expectations of shareholders, regulators, employees, and broader society

What the board does not govern is equally important. It does not manage operations. The distinction between governance and management is fundamental — the board directs; the executive team executes. When that boundary erodes, governance weakens on both sides.

Who else shares corporate governance responsibility?

While the board holds ultimate governance authority, corporate governance responsibility is shared across several roles within an organisation. The CEO, senior executives, the company secretary, board committees, and in some structures, a supervisory board all carry defined governance obligations. Effective governance depends on these roles functioning in coordination, not in isolation.

The CEO and senior leadership team are responsible for implementing board-approved strategy, maintaining internal controls, and ensuring that accurate information reaches the board in a timely manner. Their governance role is to manage within the boundaries the board sets and to be transparent when those boundaries are tested.

The company secretary plays a governance role that is often underestimated. As Lynelle Bagwandeen, Group Company Secretary at Prosus, observes, the role is not merely administrative. As secretarial support to the board, a skilled company secretary contributes to smooth and considered decision-making — facilitating the board’s processes, ensuring compliance with procedural requirements, and acting as a bridge between the board and executive management. The role demands that personal ego be set aside entirely in service of the governance function.

In two-tier board structures, common in the Netherlands and Germany, the supervisory board holds a distinct oversight mandate separate from the management board. Supervisory board members like Jeanine Helthuis observe that the two bodies need each other and strengthen each other — engaging in deeper, more frequent consultation on governance, ESG, stakeholder interests, and strategic developments than a unitary board structure typically allows.

What is the difference between the board chair and the CEO in governance?

The board chair leads the board; the CEO leads the organisation. In governance terms, the chair is responsible for the effectiveness of the board itself — its composition, dynamics, decision-making quality, and relationship with the executive team. The CEO is accountable to the board for the performance and management of the organisation. Separating these roles is a cornerstone of sound corporate governance.

The chair’s governance responsibilities include setting the board’s agenda, ensuring that all directors contribute meaningfully, managing the relationship with the CEO, and creating the conditions for honest, rigorous deliberation. A strong chair does not dominate — they facilitate the collective wisdom of the board while holding the CEO appropriately to account.

The CEO’s governance role is to lead management, implement board decisions, and ensure the board receives the information it needs to govern well. A CEO who withholds information, oversteps strategic boundaries, or resists board oversight creates governance risk regardless of how strong their operational performance may be.

The relationship between chair and CEO is one of the most consequential dynamics in any organisation. When it functions well, it enables both governance and management to operate at their best. When it breaks down, the effects ripple across the entire organisation. This is one reason why experienced governance advisors pay close attention to this relationship as a leading indicator of board health.

How do board committees fit into governance accountability?

Board committees extend the board’s governance capacity by focusing specialist attention on defined areas of oversight. The most common — audit, remuneration, and nomination committees — each carry specific governance accountabilities that the full board delegates to them, while retaining ultimate responsibility for the decisions those committees inform.

The audit committee governs financial reporting integrity, the relationship with external auditors, and the adequacy of internal controls. The remuneration committee governs executive pay structures, ensuring they align with long-term performance and stakeholder expectations. The nomination committee governs board composition, succession planning, and the criteria by which directors are selected and evaluated.

Committees do not replace the full board’s governance role — they deepen it. A committee’s recommendations come back to the full board for consideration, and the board remains collectively accountable for the outcomes. This structure works well when committees are genuinely independent, properly resourced, and report transparently to the full board. It breaks down when committees become isolated silos or when their work is treated as a formality rather than a substantive governance function.

The growing complexity of the governance environment — including ESG oversight, digital transformation, and cybersecurity risk — has led many boards to establish additional committees or to expand existing mandates. This reflects the evolving nature of what boards are expected to govern, not a dilution of the full board’s ultimate authority.

When does governance responsibility shift during a leadership crisis?

During a leadership crisis — whether that involves the sudden departure of a CEO, a governance failure, a reputational emergency, or a conflict at board level — governance responsibility intensifies and becomes more concentrated at the board level. The board cannot delegate its way through a crisis. It must step forward, exercise clear authority, and act decisively in the interests of the organisation.

In practice, this means the board chair assumes a more visible and active role, often working in close coordination with the company secretary and legal counsel. The board may need to convene more frequently, make decisions with incomplete information, and communicate with regulators, investors, and other stakeholders directly rather than through management.

CEO succession is one of the most consequential governance responsibilities a board faces, and the boards that navigate it best are those that have prepared in advance. The principle that succession planning should begin on the day of appointment reflects a governance philosophy that treats leadership continuity as an ongoing responsibility, not a reactive one. Boards that treat succession as an emergency measure rather than a strategic priority tend to make poor appointments under pressure.

A crisis also tests the quality of relationships within the board itself. Effective boards, as governance experience consistently shows, are able to deal with difficult situations without straining collaborative relationships. They approach adversity with the same rigour and collegiality they bring to routine governance — because the foundations of trust and honest dialogue were built before the crisis arrived.

How can a board assess whether it is fulfilling its governance role?

A board assesses its governance effectiveness through structured, honest evaluation — examining not just what decisions were made, but how the board functions as a collective leadership body. This includes the quality of its deliberations, the clarity of its oversight, the strength of its relationships, and its alignment with the organisation’s long-term strategic direction. Compliance alone is not a measure of effectiveness.

The most rigorous approach to board effectiveness evaluation goes well beyond reviewing meeting minutes or ticking regulatory boxes. It asks the difficult questions: Does the board have the right knowledge and skills for where the organisation is heading? Are directors genuinely challenging management, or deferring too readily? Is the culture of the boardroom one that encourages candour, or one that suppresses dissent?

The focus of board evaluations has shifted significantly in recent years. Attention to compliance-related matters alone is no longer sufficient. This shift reflects the changing role of board members — from passive overseers to proactive, engaged partners of management. A board that only evaluates whether it has met its procedural obligations has set the bar far too low.

Self-assessment has value, but it has limits. Directors evaluating their own collective performance are subject to the same blind spots and relational dynamics that may be contributing to the governance gaps they are trying to identify. External evaluation, conducted by advisors with no stake in the outcome, provides the objectivity that self-assessment cannot.

The most effective boards do not view evaluation as a duty. They treat it as a genuine instrument for improvement — a starting point for a multi-year development journey, not a one-time exercise in compliance.

How The Board Practice helps boards govern more effectively

The Board Practice works exclusively at board level, helping organisations answer the governance questions that matter most. For boards seeking to understand whether they are genuinely fulfilling their governance role, the firm offers the following:

  • Fully customised board effectiveness evaluations — from structured self-assessment to comprehensive external evaluation of the board, its committees, and individual members
  • Forward-looking analysis — focused on strategic direction, board dynamics, culture, and leadership capability, not retrospective compliance
  • Honest, independent feedback — delivered without bias, grounded in a methodology refined over 19 years and more than 120 board assignments across continents and industries
  • Multi-year development planning — defining a two to three-year development path, monitored in close partnership with the Chair
  • AI-powered self-assessment tools — for boards seeking ongoing evaluation capability between external engagements

Corporate governance is only as strong as the board’s willingness to examine itself with the same rigour it applies to the organisation it oversees. If your board is ready for that conversation, get in touch with The Board Practice to discuss how a tailored evaluation can strengthen your governance and equip your board for the challenges ahead.

Related Articles